Sunday September 10 2017
Roma identity crisis

Atletico Madrid come to the Olimpico with a consolidated style, writes Richard Hall, but the new Roma are still a mystery.

Roma welcome Atletico Madrid to the Stadio Olimpico in a game that sees Lazio’s very own Diego Simeone return to his former hunting ground but more tellingly, it will act as a marker towards their progress this term. It’s a tough test for Eusebio Di Francesco and his men, who up until now have not managed to get into their stride.

It is hard to tell whether it would have been beneficial for the Romans to have faced Sampdoria this weekend, a game called off due to floods. It is true that they have managed to rest players and should, in theory, look sharp against a difficult Atleti team. They will certainly need all their industry to get a result, especially as they have looked inconsistent in their first two games.

Against Atalanta on the opening day they looked slow and laboured. It is true that Bergamo is never an easy place to go and play your football, but it had been anticipated that whilst Roma were without Mohamed Salah (after he moved to Liverpool), under Di Francesco they would be able to move the ball quickly and keep hold of that cavalier approach ingrained in them by ex-mister Luciano Spalletti. The game developed in to a turgid affair, but nevertheless the Romans won by a single goal and returned to the Capital with a clean sheet and the excuse it was the opening day.

The stars seemed to have aligned in the following game against Inter, when they came out of the block at a terrifying rate of knots. Edin Dzeko had given them an early lead and, if the woodwork had not intervened on more than one occasion, they could have been out of sight. The credit should go to Inter for the comeback, but even so Roma dropped off in the final 30 minutes and conceded three goals.

By the final whistle the fans were left with an early season conundrum: which team are we? Were they the dogged and hard to beat side that faced Atalanta? The three goals here suggested not. The answer was that it was too early to tell.

It is to this effect that it was perhaps a shame the match at Marassi was called off, as it would have given Di Francesco another chance to assess his side against a capable opposition.  Sampdoria have started the season brightly and it would have been a good test before Atleti come to town. The group consists of the two mentioned teams, English champions Chelsea and tricky Qarabag, the Coach himself admitting that they cannot underestimate them.  

Does Di Francesco set up with the intention of containing Atleti? The Spaniards have been energetic and the youthful squad has attacked their opponents from the off this season with ruthless effect, just look at the 1-5 demolition of Las Palmas for an example.  Simeone himself has said this year that his team’s energy and dynamism ultimately should result in damage to other teams, but can Roma contain this? If the Giallorossi Coach decides to attack as he did against Inter, then he may well beat Simeone at his own game. Then again, the result also could be catastrophic.

Fans of Roma will flock to the Olimpico on Tuesday night in ponderous mood. Just exactly who are Roma this year? Will this set the benchmark for their future performances? Does this team have the right balance? Does it have the strength in depth?

After the Champions League draw, the Roma Coach said of Simeone’s teams that they do not play beautiful football, but he could appreciate why they have managed to get so far in the competition. This in his opinion was because the team worked hard for the Coach and for each other. He will have to expect this as a bare minimum from his team as they continue to search for their own identity. If those elements don’t come together quickly, the mood could quickly turn sour in the Capital.

Have your say...
EDF said post the draw that Athleti's style was not pretty and that they don't play good football. For a man I respect, I think he will have shrunk by two inches after tonight's game. Athleti if not for Alisson absolutely mauled Roma. Goals don't have to always be scored to see and witness a huge gulf in class.
on the 12th September, 2017 at 9:35pm
No identity? It's two games into the season.. Last week there was some trash article saying that Schick is no good for us. The writers on this site really have it in for Roma.

How about the Chinese teams who just bought ten new players each. How is their identity?
on the 12th September, 2017 at 11:50am
In a strange way Roma do look better off in terms of squad depth but they don't look 2 have as formidable a starting 11.At least on paper.They did manage to get 1 big name in after the huge losses of Salah,Rudiger n Pjanic in past 2 yrs but I don't think they'll genuinely compete until the new Stadio is built!But if Schick starts where he left off,if Under integrates well n if the defense n team can gel under EDF then they'll still have a good season! They'll do well 2 get a draw v Atleti tho :)
on the 12th September, 2017 at 7:09am
It's a massive game for Roma.

Win it, and they have a real chance of progression. Lose it, and they're already looking at EL spot for 3rd.

AM are favourites, but probably aren't the force they were a few years ago.

Roma will probably fall short in this group, but there's no excuse for not going very far in the EL if they end up in that.
on the 12th September, 2017 at 12:10am

Post new comment

Your email address is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
If you have your own website, enter its address here.
Maximum 500 characters.
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Enter the characters shown in the image.
Your responses will be moderated, and sometimes edited, by Football Italia before appearing on the site. Your data may be made public and you accept our Privacy Policy. Please keep your comments clean and try to keep them relevant to the blog above. We reserve the right to reject views that we deem unsuitable for publication.