Monday April 16 2018
Buffon storm must end

Gigi Buffon must find a way to both express his passion and calm the media frenzy that risks damaging his reputation, writes Richard Thomas.

The extent of the furore caused by Gigi Buffon's reaction to the Real Madrid penalty has gone too far - but the Italy number one should apologise in full.

Make no mistake - what the 40-year-old did was wrong. Although understandable in the heat of the moment, his initial, aggressive reaction to Michael Oliver's decision to award Los Blancos an injury time spot-kick in last week's Champions League quarter final second leg was wrong. He was deservedly shown a red card for foul-mouthed dissent and with it, the chance to save Cristiano Ronaldo's winning penalty.

It was also wrong of Buffon to heap ridicule on Oliver post-match, accusing the Englishman of having “a rubbish bin for a heart” and that he should have been “in the stand...eating crisps and drinking Sprite” rather than officiating a match between two heavyweights of world football.

Buffon's hysterical comments caused Oliver a great deal of offence - both professionally and personally - culminating in the sad news that he and his wife had received death threats in the days that followed the controversy at the Bernabeu. Though obviously not the perpetrator of that crime, Buffon must see that his comments were the catalyst for the events that followed.

Finally, it was wrong of Buffon to stop short of a full apology when questioned on the matter in the build up to Juve's Serie A match with Sampdoria on Sunday. Though the goalkeeper admitted he would have used 'different words' to criticise Oliver with the benefit of hindsight, he by and large stood by his comments - comments that did a lot of damage to the reputations of both Oliver and himself.

This is not to say that Buffon must admit Oliver was right to award the spot-kick. Although in my opinion it was the correct decision, football was, is and always will be the world's most hotly-debated sport. The Juve shot-stopper is fully entitled to disagree with the decision and criticise it if he sees fit.

Though petty and not at all to be condoned, neither was Buffon's on-field reaction to Oliver's decision unique in the slightest. What's more, it received the punishment it warranted at the time. It wasn't pretty to watch and undermined the various ongoing campaigns from football's governing bodies to show officials greater levels of respect, but Buffon is far, far from alone in having crossed that line.

To suggest, as some have, that the veteran's legacy will be tainted when he hangs up his gloves for good because he showed dissent is absurd. Comparisons to Zinedine Zidane’s headbutt on Marco Materazzi in the 2006 World Cup are equally ludicrous. Shouting at a referee after a contentious decision is hardly the same thing as GBH.

Buffon is also far, far from alone in criticising match officials in the aftermath of a closely-fought contest. What he should apologise for are his choice of words and - most importantly - the ramifications that they caused for Oliver on a human level. 

Buffon justified his post-match rant by saying his passionate outburst was merely a case of his being who he is - 'I am Gigi Buffon.' That is the problem. Those who are pointing to his famous comment that he wouldn’t have told the referee Sulley Muntari’s ‘phantom’ goal was over the line, even if he had seen it behind his head, are missing the crux of the matter.

It would be easy to apologise unreservedly and sweep the whole thing under the carpet, but he wouldn’t mean it. It would’ve been easy to say he’d confess to the Milan goal, but it wouldn’t have been true. Honesty is not always the best policy and it certainly isn’t when dealing with the delicate diplomacy of international football.

If he could be the Gigi Buffon who, as Max Allegri rightly said, has by and large been an exemplary and classy role model throughout his glittering 20-year career, it would draw a line under this media storm that has been howling ever since. 

Have your say...
what are silly article , maybe you should stop writing garbage and put more thought in your stories
on the 16th April, 2018 at 4:06am
ciao amici!
as a fan of Juve I would like to apologize to Michael Oliver for the DEATH THREATS that's absolutely unacceptable !! if some body made wrong decision ! you train them not kill them!
as far as Buffon is concerned! without a doubt he did the right thing AS WE ARE ALL FED UP with UEFA/FIFA !!
Buffon reaction was a CRY FOR JUSTICE!
Oliver made sure Juve will lose by taking them to 10 men there was no need for that!
VAR should be set up in CL!
on the 16th April, 2018 at 3:57am
says who?
move on englishman.
on the 16th April, 2018 at 3:42am
Totally, 100% with Buffon!

The corrupt Oliver?

An animal!
He robbed with great culpability the NAZIONE BIANCONERA!

A living legend.
A true to life GOOD GUY!
Best goalkeeper in the World ever!

Important events like the CL cannot be tarnished by an Oliver qualunque!!!

on the 16th April, 2018 at 3:15am
Rubish. This is already water under the bridge. He doesn't have to do anything because their's nothing to do at this point. He expressed his anger and later mentioned that he went overboard. He's not responsible if crazy ppl come out of the word work and threaten the ref. He never threatened the ref or encouraged others to to do that so gtf out of here if you think he should get on his knees and ask for forgiveness.
on the 16th April, 2018 at 3:10am
I sincerely hope he doesn't issue a full apology. I'm so glad he came out and expressed himself unreservedly. In this age of pathetic neo feminists and obsession with political correctness, it's a breath of fresh air seeing someone express himself honestly, candidly, and in an unfiltered manner. Enough with lies and hypocrisy.
on the 16th April, 2018 at 2:58am
It is very easy to sit on the couch eating chips and drink Coke and judge somebody like Buffon. Gigi says what he wants to say and nobody can not shut him up. It is HIS OPINION and he has all right in the world to express it since he was the one involved in it and got sent off. Reading some of the articles here makes me think that they are written by high school haters.
on the 16th April, 2018 at 2:25am
What a ridiculous blog!

Buffon should not apologise. I for one completely agree with him that it was not a penalty. I’m a Milan supporter so don’t try using that as justification of what I am saying. It should have gone to extra time, a 50/50 call in that situation if not clear cut should have allowed extra time

How is it that a man (who you rightly stated) committed GBH in a World Cup final is allowed anywhere near a football pitch again, let alone managing Real Madrid. Yet we condemn Buffon?
on the 16th April, 2018 at 2:08am

Post new comment

Your email address is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
If you have your own website, enter its address here.
Maximum 500 characters.
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Enter the characters shown in the image.
Your responses will be moderated, and sometimes edited, by Football Italia before appearing on the site. Your data may be made public and you accept our Privacy Policy. Please keep your comments clean and try to keep them relevant to the blog above. We reserve the right to reject views that we deem unsuitable for publication.