Tuesday July 31 2018
Should Juventus take Bonucci back?

Juventus should think twice about swapping Mattia Caldara for Leonardo Bonucci, writes Anthony Barbagallo.

While Juventus have been keeping active in this summer transfer window rebuilding a new-look side for the future, it appears a return for Leonardo Bonucci is very much in the pipeline. But is it worth Juve giving up Mattia Caldara - one of Italy’s brightest prospects - to re-sign a 31-year-old defender?

Bonucci stunned Juve before the start of last season by joining Serie A rivals AC Milan for a fee of €42 million, this left a bitter taste in the mouths of many Bianconeri. The departure came as a shock after the centre-back played a pivotal role in the core of the Juventus defence for seven years - helping win six consecutive Serie A Scudetti, three Coppa Italia titles and reaching two Champions League finals in three years.

But since the 4-1 loss to Real Madrid last year, the reported halftime bust-up in the final between Bonucci and some of his former teammates only dampened his relationship with the club. If the Old Lady is to re-sign Bonucci, the relationship between the defender, team, Coach and the club’s fans may still be fragile.

Moving to San Siro to transform Milan as Andrea Pirlo had done when moving the other way, the past season didn’t pan out how the Rossoneri captain had envisaged. Milan finished in sixth place in Serie A, crashed out to Arsenal in the Last 16 of the Europa League and ownership problems were brewing behind the scenes.

Set against that backdrop it’s not difficult to comprehend why Bonucci wants a return to Turin. The 2016 Serie A Footballer of the Year wants to be back competing on the domestic and Champions League stages and is even willing to accept a pay cut. However, the Caldara-Bonucci swap doesn’t seem to make sense from a Juventus point of view, especially the part that involves selling Caldara to a direct rival. 

The Bianconeri been lauded for their wisdom when it comes to undertaking transfer business, however, this time Milan could reap the benefits from this proposed deal. Caldara is currently in better form than Bonucci, having been consistently exceptional for Atalanta over the past two seasons. The Italian youngster is tipped to be the long-term replacement for Juventus captain Giorgio Chiellini and Andrea Barzagli - that’s why the Serie A giants invested in the 24-year-old in 2017. The Bergamo-born defender has already experienced Europa League football with La Dea and is now eyeing the opportunity to ply his trade in this season’s Champions League with his new club.

A quiet achiever, the Atalanta academy product is a complete modern day centre-back most Coaches dream of having at their disposal: strong in clean tackles, good at ball interceptions and a set-piece threat in aerial situations. Why would the Bianconeri want to let go of a defender who boasts great qualities and can hone them alongside none other than veteran defender Chiellini?

The fact that Caldara played exceptionally well for a smaller Serie A club - alongside average defenders - indicates he is a capable leader and adaptable defender. However, Bonucci isn’t as versatile as most calcio fans think. The Italian international has thrived in the past BBC partnership at Juventus and the Azzurri, but this past season suggested that 31-year-old generally struggled without Chiellini and Barzagli by his side.

Bonucci returning to the reigning Serie A champions may bring immediate and short-term success, especially in the club’s quest to claim a third Champions League title. But let’s face it, both Chiellini and Barzagli are not getting any younger and will not be far off from hanging their boots up. If Bonucci moves back to Turin, who will play alongside the Italian when Chiellini and Barzagli leave? Daniele Rugani might be an option, but he too might leave sooner than expected. If this Caldara-Bonucci swap goes ahead, it will only highlight the major issue calcio currently faces - the young Italian talent being pushed aside to accommodate older players.

The safe option for the Bianconeri here would be to keep Caldara and give this talented youngster a chance to prove himself at a high calibre club like Juventus.

Have your say...
on the 31st July, 2018 at 10:14am

Calabria, Caldara, Romagnoli, Conti ( i mean cmon..)

Bonaventura, Kessie, Rodrigues,

Hakan, Higuin, Suso

Sub, Cutrone, Locatelli, Biglia etc

To me that looks pretty darn solid
on the 31st July, 2018 at 10:10am
This swap is one transfer I don't understand at all, but I trust Juve management team and I hope they don't fail us the fans!
on the 31st July, 2018 at 10:09am
With all respect to Bonucci`s skills

Never ever would i give up Caldara, definetly not as a straight swap. (only with buy back clause)

Bonucci`s + Money , maybe.....but i think thats just me saying I don`t want it :D
on the 31st July, 2018 at 9:56am
No way.
Juventus don't need Bonucci,and the most juve fans don't want him back.
Juve want to lift the champions league cup and they want a top defender, but they can buy Godin with 20m and hold Caldara.
The problem is Higuain,juve can't sell him for 55-60m and only Milan will buy him, but only with Caldara.
My opinion is that juve must keep Caldara ( he is much better player als Rugani ).
on the 31st July, 2018 at 9:56am
This is the worst deal for Juve. Please please keep Caldara and Rugani
on the 31st July, 2018 at 9:56am
I agree, it seems that Juventus are so fixated on UCL success that all logic is going out the window.

Bonucci was excellent for Juventus, but he made his bed so let him lie in it. Why take him back with his tail between his legs when he isn't needed? He was terrible for Milan last year.

his deal strengthens Milan, there's no doubt that they benefit from it, long term and possibly even short term, too... they can build on Romangnoli and Caldara for years to come, now. And if Conte arrives....
on the 31st July, 2018 at 9:50am
Agree. After all Bonucci has never really been a good defender, last season with Milan showed who he really was. Without Chiellini, Barzagli & Buffon, he was helpless.
Swapping one of the most promising defenders for a 31-year-old clumsy one is suicide move by Juve. What if Rugani was also sold in the end?
Let's face it, most of Juve defenders are not young anymore.
on the 31st July, 2018 at 9:47am
bonucci is overrated. his only attribute is his passing from the back. positionally he is a horrible. in the two c.league finals he was the worst defender. caldara will be the next best thing. the whole thing is shocking to me. I can only imagine the juve fans booing this guy bonucci when ever he touches the ball.why would you want to create that will never love this guy again.thuram was a great player for juve but not a fan wanted his star at the stadium. bonucci makes no sense
on the 31st July, 2018 at 9:44am
i honestly hope this doesn't happen, big mistake from Juventus. at least have a buy back clause for caldara
on the 31st July, 2018 at 9:42am
Not even read the article... But no! That ship has sailed and he made his decision. That's as far as I consider it.
on the 31st July, 2018 at 9:39am
The only logical option for Juve is to insert buyback option, in order to achieve win-win solution. Juve gets good and capable CB, while Caldara gets more playing time in an environment with slightly less pressure compared to Juve.
on the 31st July, 2018 at 9:35am

Post new comment

Your email address is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
If you have your own website, enter its address here.
Maximum 500 characters.
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Enter the characters shown in the image.
Your responses will be moderated, and sometimes edited, by Football Italia before appearing on the site. Your data may be made public and you accept our Privacy Policy. Please keep your comments clean and try to keep them relevant to the blog above. We reserve the right to reject views that we deem unsuitable for publication.