Saturday December 1 2018
Fiorentina-Juventus, anatomy of a rivalry

The grudge match between Fiorentina and Juventus runs deep, fuelled by decades of attrition and controversy, writes Anthony Barbagallo.

Try picturing a sea of purple flags, banners and over 40,000 Viola tifosi chanting “Oh Fiorentina” at their top their lungs throughout the iconic Stadio Artemio Franchi. The ultras in the Curva Fiesole shouting words like “ladri” (thieves) at the Juventus team – even though these current Bianconeri players weren’t around during the 1980s and 90s. This is the hostile environment Cristiano Ronaldo and Co. will experience this evening. It is only in Florence that this hate-filled rivalry evokes stronger memories of bitterness between the pair.

This unorthodox rivalry has been built around controversy and hatred. It is not a typical geographical and competitive derby: it’s all about getting redemption, mainly from a Fiorentina point of view. And when Juventus always travels to the city of Florence, it’s not like the away fans can easily walk around the city’s piazzas wearing the black-and-white striped shirt. From controversial incidents on the pitch to Juve purchasing the Viola’s stars, these events have turned this rivalry into one of the most intense football clashes on the Peninsula.

Apart from Juve thumping the Viola 11-0 in their first ever meeting, this unique rivalry didn’t ignite until the early 1980s. Approaching the last matchday of the 1981-82 Serie A season level on 44 points with Juventus, Fiorentina seemed poised in claiming their third Scudetto. Making a 536km trip to the island of Sardinia, the Tuscan side needed a victory against relegation candidates Cagliari and hope that the Bianconeri would fall short against an in-form Catanzaro in Calabria.

At the time, both Fiorentina and Juventus boasted their own individual quality. The Bianconeri’s Sicilian core – compromising of Claudio Gentile, Giuseppe Furino and Gaetano Scirea – kept the backline and midfield compact. Dino Zoff and Paolo Rossi were the other talents that made this a formidable Juve side to compete against. The Viola were also packed with talent: Giancarlo Antognoni, Antonello Cuccureddu and Pietro Vierchowod to name a few.

With the Cagliari-Fiorentina game remaining scoreless at halftime, the Gigliati thought they had found the breakthrough in the second half through their forward Francesco Graziani. However, the goal ended up being disallowed as referee Maurizio Mattei spotted a foul on the Cagliari goalkeeper in the lead up to the goal – leaving Fiorentina fans bewildered and outraged.

With Fiorentina’s shortcomings in the Sardinian capital, Juventus also looked like emulating a stalemate with a persistent Catanzaro outfit. While the Calabrian side had been denied a penalty, Juve ended up winning one at the other end. It was Liam Brady’s cool finish from the spot-kick that gifted the Old Lady a 1-0 win and seal a 20th Scudetto. After the controversial decisions, a furious Carlo Antognoni described the situation as a theft – one that deprived the Viola in claiming its third Serie A title. These extraordinary events are what shaped this into one Italy’s most bitter rivalries. 

After the 1981-82 campionato fiasco, Juventus marched on to claim two more Serie A titles that decade. For Fiorentina, their inconsistency resulted in mixed fortunes. It wasn’t until the 1989-90 season that the Juventus-Fiorentina rivalry relit once again. With the Viola experiencing a lacklustre campaign domestically, it was their talismanic forward Roberto Baggio who guided the Tuscans all the way to the 1990 UEFA Cup Final. With all the other European opponents Fiorentina could have potentially faced, it had to be their bitter enemies Juventus waiting on the horizon. Being the first all-Italian final in the tournament’s history, a worldwide audience was about to get a taste of this fierce showdown.  

This anticipated final was played over two legs, the first one in Turin and the second in Avellino – the Stadio Artemio Franchi was undergoing renovations in preparation for the 1990 FIFA World Cup. With almost playing their home fixtures at the Stadio Renato Curi in Perugia, a pitch invasion from the Viola supporters in the semi-final clash against Werder Bremen forced the Gigliati to find another temporary home stadium. Not only was Fiorentina playing 500km away from home, but it was also a concern for the club and its fans that the Bianconeri boasted numerous Juventini in Italy’s south.

The first leg in Turin was another typical Fiorentina-Juventus match that resulted in controversial circumstances. The Turin giants took a 1-0 lead in the third minute after Toto Schillaci cut the ball back to set up his Sicilian compatriot Roberto Galia for the goal. But the Old Lady’s lead only lasted for seven minutes, with Fiorentina’s Renato Buso scoring a crucial equaliser off a cross. With the game delicately poised at 1-1, a dubious decision in the 59th minute sparked heated debates. It was Juve’s Pierluigi Casiraghi who fired the Bianconeri in front, however, the officials failed to notice Casiraghi’s push on Fiorentina’s defender Celeste Pin in the lead up to the goal. Once again, the Viola supporters were left infuriated.

Juventus would eventually make it 3-1 in the 73rd minute – putting them in a commanding position for the second leg. After the game, the word that some Fiorentina players and fans were shouting was “ladri” (thieves). In the second leg in Avellino, the Gigliati had been nullified – keeping the firepower of Baggio, Buso, Dunga and Marco Nappi quiet. 

With older Viola supporters having to endure the painful 1981-82 Serie A and 1990 UEFA Cup final losses, Baggio’s transfer to Juventus in 1990 inflamed the fragile relationship between the club’s fans. Il Divin Codino was sold for a world-record fee of £8 million – causing chaos in the streets of Florence. And when the Bianconeri took on Fiorentina at the Stadio Artemio Franchi in 1991, Baggio refused to take a penalty – claiming the Viola goalkeeper Gianmatteo Mareggini knew the way the Italian striker took them. Luigi De Agostini took the penalty instead – having his kick saved by Mareggini.

As soon as Baggio was substituted, he picked up a Fiorentina scarf that was thrown near him and comfortably wrapped it around his neck. His surprising actions captured the eyes of many Calcio fans and the media’s attention across the nation. “Deep in my heart I am always purple,” an emotional Baggio stated after the game. While this was a warming gesture for the Viola’s tifosi, some Juventus supporters were left fuming.

While Baggio was accumulating the goals for the Bianconeri front line in 1993, Fiorentina was playing its football in Serie B. But the Viola also boasted a star of their own – Argentine hero Gabriel Batistuta. Between 1995 and 2000, Fiorentina’s formidable attacking duo of Batistuta and Rui Costa gave the club immense domestic success throughout this period.

Claiming two Coppa Italia titles and mustering a couple of top-four finishes, these achievements ended up being some of the best-cherished memories for Viola fans. The Tuscans didn’t need Baggio anymore – they had Batistuta. La Vecchia Signora also enjoyed a successful spell in the mid-1990s, especially in the 1995-96 campaign when Marcello Lippi guided them to their second Champions League trophy. 

After Batistuta left Fiorentina in 2000, the Viola only declined. The Gigliati declared bankruptcy in 2002 -  the Della Valle brothers taking over the club and renaming it Florentia Viola. Playing in Serie C and watching their enemies Juventus claim their 27th Scudetto, it was difficult for Viola supporters to digest. During their one season stint in Italy’s third tier, the Toscani still boasted some quality midfielders and attackers in Christian Rigano and Angelo Di Livio. Both of these club legends contributed to the Viola’s Serie A promotion in 2004. 

With Juventus still winning Serie A titles and Fiorentina licking their wounds after the bankruptcy, the 2006 Calciopoli scandal rocked both clubs. Juve was sent to Serie B and was stripped of their two recent titles. The Viola had been given a 15-point penalty the following season. For once, it was Fiorentina fans who had the ascendency – relishing every moment seeing their bitter rivals playing second division football. 

In 2013, the Viola fans were sent into euphoria after Vincenzo Montella’s Fiorentina side had beaten Juventus 4-2 – their first win against the Bianconeri at the Stadio Artemio Franchi in 15 years. Trailing 2-0 at halftime, the Gigliati made an incredible second-half comeback thanks to a Giuseppe Rossi hat-trick. The momentous victory wasn’t against any Juve team – it was against a well-drilled side coached by Antonio Conte.

With the Fiorentina-Juventus rivalry only being aggravated by some on-field debatable decisions in past fixtures, the bitterness between both clubs has always been strongly present in the transfer market. Baggio’s transfer to Juve wasn’t the only time the Viola lost an Italian prodigy. In the middle of 2017, Federico Bernardeschi didn’t have intentions in renewing his contract with the Tuscan club – presenting Juve with the opportunity to sign the Tuscan star for €40m.

With the vile insults Bernardeschi received before departing to Turin, his return to Florence last season was a hostile one. However, it was probably one of the best games the 24-year-old has played so far in the black and white stripes. No Fiorentina fan will forget when his stunning free-kick silenced the home supporters and helped the Bianconeri cruise to a 2-0 victory. The courage Bernardeschi mustered when he celebrated his goal in front of his former club was a spectacle that many Juventini savoured.

With Bernardeschi having a decent chance of getting some playing time in this fixture, will we see the Tuscan winger cause havoc again in Florence? For Fiorentina, the last time they beat their fierce rival was two seasons ago – when Chiesa caused many headaches for Gianluigi Buffon and the ‘BBC’ defence in that 2-1 win. But with Juve yet to lose a game in this season’s Serie A, can Fiorentina – one of the youngest sides in Europe – defeat this experienced side with their attacking weapons Chiesa and Giovanni Simeone?

All these talking points have the potential in making this another classic and bitter Fiorentina-Juventus affair.

Watch Serie A live in the UK on Premier Sports and get your first month free. £5.99 thereafter until September with promo code: ITALIA

Have your say...
@Scottazzurri, the author is correct. Gaetano Scirea and Claudio Gentile both came from Sicilian parents - that makes them Sicilian, end of story. You have to sometimes read beyond a Wikipedia page.
on the 3rd December, 2018 at 10:41pm
Sicilian core????
Only Beppe Furino was from Palermo...........As far as I'm aware Gaetano Scirea was from Lombardia, (A small town near Milan) and Claudio Gentile was from Tripoli in Libya and settled in Lombardia too.....
Check facts before spouting this nonsense
on the 3rd December, 2018 at 7:45am
Meh. Pls stop calling Fiorentina-Juventus "a rivalry". It's obsolete nowadays.
on the 3rd December, 2018 at 3:34am
fiorentina have been in years of stagnation than decline the fact that they selling the few youth players they are producing to other Italian clubs shows a continued lack of ambition from the owners to develop the club. It is more than frustrating to see another Italian club not taking advantage of their academy for short term gains.

The current ownership thought nothing of selling bernardeschi melo chiellini and melo to juve so i guess they are immune from this rivalry.
on the 2nd December, 2018 at 8:08pm
Isn't Fiorentina now a just a Juventus feeder club. The Chiesa transfer in the summer will either prove or disprove this theory.
on the 2nd December, 2018 at 6:07am
@dude i was thinking the same thing lol
on the 1st December, 2018 at 6:55pm
What makes Serie-A the best league isn't just it's Tactical superiority but also Nostalgic dramas and evergreen heated rivalry between fans and teams so to speak....THE LEGEND LIVES ON
on the 1st December, 2018 at 5:48pm
Only Fiorentina consider this a grudge match. For Juve this is just another fixture.
on the 1st December, 2018 at 5:26pm
Great article. Though I wish the author mentioned Carlos Tevez doing Batistuta's machine gun celebration in Florence before that second half collapse.
on the 1st December, 2018 at 3:37pm
Bernardeschi to score again..
on the 1st December, 2018 at 12:45pm

Post new comment

Your email address is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
If you have your own website, enter its address here.
Maximum 500 characters.
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Enter the characters shown in the image.
Your responses will be moderated, and sometimes edited, by Football Italia before appearing on the site. Your data may be made public and you accept our Privacy Policy. Please keep your comments clean and try to keep them relevant to the blog above. We reserve the right to reject views that we deem unsuitable for publication.