Tuesday December 11 2018
Di Francesco or Conte for Roma?

Roma might sack Coach Eusebio Di Francesco to replace him with Antonio Conte, and Andrea Tallarita weighs up which option is best.

There are games so painful that they make one question whether being a sports fan is really worth it, and Roma's catastrophic, suicidal, 2-2 draw against Cagliari was just that kind of game. When the final whistle blew, Coach Eusebio Di Francesco could be seen laughing helplessly, like Lovecraft's sailor Briden at the sight of the Cthulhu monster.

In this season of senselessness, the new day dawned after the cataclysm and brought with it no consequences whatsoever. Draws for Lazio and Milan (one of them no less incredible than the Lupi's) meant that nothing changed in the standings. Roma withdrew into a training retreat, sure, but the club confirmed their faith in Di Francesco shortly thereafter. Carry on as usual.

Below that veneer of normality, of course, DiFra's position is in reality increasingly precarious, and it may be only the lack of plausible alternatives that has kept him on his seat. The likes of Vincenzo Montella, Laurent Blanc and Paulo Sousa inspire nobody, but one name is being circulated that would make the fans happy: former Juventus, Italy and Chelsea's Antonio 'Veni-Vidi-Vici' Conte.

Everyone already agrees that the 49-year-old is a highly unlikely option for Roma – he is invariably troublesome, legally embroiled with Chelsea, and hugely expensive – but things are looking so bad in the capital, that reports suggest Francesco Totti himself is trying to cajole the quarrelsome tactician into a return to Serie A.

So, with unmerciful disaster striking Roma again and again, should President James Pallotta sign Conte as soon as he has the chance? The answer is: not exactly.

Roma should consider the possibility of sacking Di Francesco, yes. Yet doing it right now would be a massive strategic error, even if Conte really were a viable alternative.

If you are not convinced, consider Roma's game tomorrow, played away to Viktoria Plzen: it may be the Italian team's most incredible game of the season precisely for being so completely irrelevant. Roma qualifying from a Champions League group with a game to spare is an astonishing occurrence which is being unjustly clouded by their domestic woes.

It is a measure of this season's wild inconsistency that Di Francesco's broken, demoralised men should represent a true force to be reckoned with in Europe's elite competition. Yet it also confirms what we already knew from last year.

DiFra is, by every estimate, as inefficient and inconclusive in Serie A as he is outstanding and surprising in the Champions League. Interestingly, this also happens to be the opposite of Antonio Conte's profile, who won championships with Juventus and Chelsea but never set the world on fire in the Champions League. In fact, he was bested by Di Francesco himself in last year's competition, when the Giallorossi scored six goals in two games against the Blues to snatch a first-place finish in Group C.

What kind of trade would Roma set themselves up for, if they swapped one man for the other? Conte would almost certainly improve the Lupi's results in Serie A – although that's sort of a given at this point, as one imagines almost any change in Coach would have that effect, at least on the short term. The downside is that their guaranteed Champions League Last 16 round would, in all the most plausible scenarios, be the end of the line for them in Europe.

On the other hand, sticking with EDF means taking a gamble in Serie A, but his track record suggests he has much better odds of reaching the Quarter-finals. If the draws are favourable, he may even have a slim chance of repeating last year's miracle and reaching the Semi-finals. Would the gamble be worth it?

In this writer's opinion, it's best to keep Di Francesco, not least because a Serie A resurgence cannot be ruled out for him. He managed to turn around a results crisis last year, and he may well do it again, especially once his key players return from injury and the winter transfer window allows for reinforcements. Even the shock of the Cagliari game, for all we know, may end up proving cathartic rather than destructive.

Trying to predict how things will turn out would be guesswork at best, but with Roma only five points away from fourth place in Serie A, it would be foolish to throw away their best shot in the Champions League for the sake of a target they may very well still reach.

Instead, Roma should wait at least until the Champions League Last Sixteen rounds before sacking their Coach. That may seem like a long way away (the games are in mid-February), but then again, these two months would represent the perfect chance for Roma to focus all their energies on the domestic front. At the very least, this would remove all remaining doubts on Di Francesco.

Even if Roma aren't fourth by February,  there is reason to hope – based on the performances of their rivals so far – that they'll still be within range of that spot. And then Pallotta would have a solid reason to bring in a new face and really rescue the last seasonal objective.

Conte is a great Coach and it would be interesting to see what he could do with Roma's squad. But he has little to fight for there, what with Juventus having a stranglehold on the Scudetto, while DiFra deserves at least the chance to try his hand again in this Champions League tournament. His club has more to lose than to win by sacking him now.

Watch Serie A live in the UK on Premier Sports for just £9.99 per month including live LaLiga, Eredivisie, Scottish Cup Football and more. Visit:

Have your say...
Why would management fire Di Francesco when he aligns so well with long term goals? Monchi was brought in to buy youth, Di Francesco to develop them. He's turned Cengiz Under into a 50mil saleable asset, guaranteed Roma second-most Italian revenue from CL, and has a fair shot at CL next season.

For better or worse management has been clear they plan to sell every year until Roma has positive cash flow. Di Francesco's the right man for that job.
on the 14th December, 2018 at 6:00am
Please... the owners need to sack themselves. They've reduced Roma to an academy developing players for ambitious clubs.
on the 13th December, 2018 at 8:35pm
Keep him. At least 4 now. They've done well in CL considering but they were well beaten by Real n unless they improve or get a good draw then I don't c em going much further. IF they r building 4 future tho then at least DiFra is good wi youth. Getting Zaniolo was inspired but 2 many top players have been sold. Key men wi experience whereas the replacements have been hit n miss. He needs more time as do Roma 2 grow but imo there's been 2 much of a player turnover n changing coach yet won't help
on the 12th December, 2018 at 11:52am
Di Fra should stay we just need a new owner who will actually invest in the team, instead of selling our best players to fund youngsters.
on the 12th December, 2018 at 1:56am
Keep the loser Di Francesco. He suits Roma perfectly! Zero titles guaranteed.
on the 11th December, 2018 at 11:16pm
It's not solely DiFra's fault. With their transfer policy, even the likes of Guardiola, Ancelotti or Mourinho will never save Roma.
Just like the article says, keep DiFra coz no more suitable replacements available.

Fire Monchi & Palotta instead LMAO.
on the 11th December, 2018 at 10:31pm
Conte wont change a thing regarding results. Just watch.

PS they will sell 2-3 starters next summer. Thats almost guaranteed...again
on the 11th December, 2018 at 8:55pm
Roma, sadly, is a club with no ambition ,and need a manager they can manipulate with. Conte is not one of them.
on the 11th December, 2018 at 7:44pm
Personally I think Conte is over hyped as a coach. As a Juve and Azzurri fan, I can't stand how he always talks so negatively about his team... He is constantly looking for scapegoats. given that EDF lost two of his best squad members, but still advanced in the CL, I'd say he should get a bit more time.
on the 11th December, 2018 at 7:32pm
I completely agree with the fact that the achievements in the CL have been clouded with our progress in Serie A. I think the team and coach still have time to get their stuff together. Firing EDF is not so smart, it would be a rash decision. There is no one at the moment good enough to replace him but Conte. Which, as Andrea stated, is highly unlikely due to multiple factors. What Roma need to do is fight it out and reach that 4th place. THEN figure out what pieces are missing in Jan/Summer.
on the 11th December, 2018 at 4:25pm
Conte or Di Francesco?

With all these highly potential youths in Roma's roosters, my faith is still on Di Francesco. Conte, despite reputation of improving the mentality of his current players, has never been known for his ability for nurturing young players. Unlike what we've seen so far from Di Francesco (his faith on youngsters at Sassuolo, Cengiz Under, and also Zaniolo).

With so many changes last summer & influx of youngsters, it's our expectations that needs to be adjusted
on the 11th December, 2018 at 4:05pm
I agree with most of these points, great article. My one critique is that Di Francesco is certainly not outstanding this year in the CL. If anything they've underperformed and haven't showed any glimpse of a resurrection. We've scraped by CSKA who were forced to play kids against us, Plzn is Plzn, and we were destroyed by Real Madrid away and beaten at home.

It will not be as easy in the knockout stages...
on the 11th December, 2018 at 2:46pm
I agree totally, noone says that this last minute goal against Cagliari is his fault.
It is just very unlucky, give him a little bit of time and we will see in beginning of March who is next?or he stays
on the 11th December, 2018 at 2:16pm

Post new comment

Your email address is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
If you have your own website, enter its address here.
Maximum 500 characters.
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Enter the characters shown in the image.
Your responses will be moderated, and sometimes edited, by Football Italia before appearing on the site. Your data may be made public and you accept our Privacy Policy. Please keep your comments clean and try to keep them relevant to the blog above. We reserve the right to reject views that we deem unsuitable for publication.