Friday July 19 2019
The many problems of Mattia Perin

A failed Benfica medical was just the latest setback for Mattia Perin, as Football Italia Chief Correspondent Richard Hall profiles the troubled goalkeeper.

The career of Mattia Perin feels like it should have been much more-straight forward. The talented goalkeeper looked destined to become one of Italy’s most established names, but injuries and an unfortunate career move saw him surprisingly poised to join Benfica this week. When reports emerged that his move had been put on hold after he failed a medical, things seemed to be falling apart for the 26-year-old. Just where did it go wrong and with the strength of Serie A’s goalkeeping roster, has he any other choice than Portugal?

Perhaps failing a medical wasn’t all that surprising, even if the move to Benfica could be postponed to January rather than cancelled altogether. It is true that the former Genoa custodian has been unlucky with injuries and has ruptured the cruciate ligament in both knees as well as having two operations in his right shoulder (all in the space of three years).

It wasn’t always like this, the former Grifone goalkeeper was tipped to be one of Italy’s rising stars, but the injuries certainly haven’t helped. He still managed to get his move to Juventus at the beginning of last season, but saw his playing time limited as Wojciech Szczesny kept him away from the top spot. The move to Turin was understandable, as why wouldn’t you want to move to Italy’s biggest club, but it seemed strange he would knowingly go there to be second choice? Especially as he was making headway with the national team.

Perin joined Genoa from his hometown club Latina in 2008. Successful loan spells at Padova and in particular Pescara put him on many club’s radars, but Genoa quickly made him their number one and he never looked back. At 6ft 2in he isn’t the tallest of goalkeepers, but his natural athleticism and superb reactions gave the impression that he was rather a spectacular goalkeeper. The height he could get when taking crosses is quite extraordinary and his bravery in close quarter saves is second to none. One has to think however, that this style may have been the cause of so many injuries.

His time at Genoa saw him often be the hero as the Grifone battled relegation after relegation, but his ability meant staying there couldn’t last forever. Whilst many in the city yearned for him to stay and become a club legend, he was always going to move on. What followed (despite talk from Inter and Napoli) was a move to Juventus, little playing time (nine games in total), injury and in the end an exit.

Whilst Benfica are a great European club and there is no doubt that Perin needed to leave for more playing time, at first it seemed strange that no Serie A club made a move. It is perhaps testament to the Italian topflight and the quality of the goalkeepers that there were no takers. Inter, Milan, Napoli, Fiorentina, Roma and Lazio all have top quality goalkeepers, whilst even Sampdoria and Genoa now have men they trust between the posts.

Torino also have a good custodian and Atalanta have a man who is emerging with a good reputation, so there simply wasn’t anywhere for Perin to go. It is quite amazing to see how in the space of a year, one of Italy’s better goalkeepers was forced to look abroad to get playing time.

The final indignity was the failed medical. This perhaps also shows why Perin’s stock has fallen so much and so quickly. Who would take a risk on him? Now he will have to go back to Turin to recover and has Gigi Buffon right back in front of him in the pecking order.

For Perin, it may be the start of a new chapter. If he can get himself fit for January, then perhaps this move to Portugal can be rekindled, become the established number one, injury free and playing Champions League football whilst winning domestic honours. For a goalkeeper of his quality, it would be a shame for this to be the beginning of the end. Let’s hope that it is instead the dawn of a new chapter.

Have your say...
These editorials are really going downhill with Richard at the helm.
on the 24th July, 2019 at 10:33am
I think we can all agree Mattia shouldn’t have gone to Juve as szczesny has grown from average to half decent. What Perrin lacks is is fitness and regular football and should be given more opportunities at Juve as surely he is the future for both Juve & Italy, Donnaruma we know is a very good keeper but for me has not developed enough and his lapses in concentration are far to frequent so the tussle for the Italy keepers shirt will be interesting especially with other young emerging talent
on the 23rd July, 2019 at 7:56pm
@ Pinturicchio: Guess you missed the second part of my post so i will repost it below:

His problem is and always was fitness. If he can dedicate himself to his fitness he is just as good as Sirigu.
on the 22nd July, 2019 at 4:08pm
As a Italy National Team Fan i say Perin was never going to be Buffon style of play or be something close to Buffon. He shouldn't have went to JUVENTUS for BIG WAGES. He should have stayed at his previous club for more experience and then should have moved to a BIG CLUB if they give him guarantees for Number 1 place. These days some younger bright future players they want to get Higher Wages and move to clubs which don't work out very well.
on the 21st July, 2019 at 7:44pm

Should I give you a compilation of the mind-numbingly stupid howlers Donnarumma has conceded - like the one in the U21 Euros from 45 yards out? Or maybe rerun the times De Gea stops certain goals, only to concede a soft goal and let his team down - like his moronic display against CR7 in the Spain 3-3 Portugal match?

I never said Perin is Buffon, I said seldom. That goal by Sturaro was stupid, but not Perin's fault.

Anyway, I'm not here to debate, but to discuss...
on the 20th July, 2019 at 5:45am
@ Pinturicchio: "Perin seldom concedes goals via howlers" maybe this will refresh your memory:

His problem is and always was fitness. If he can dedicate himself to his fitness he is just as good as Sirigu.
on the 19th July, 2019 at 7:40pm
sketchy business, sturaro moves to sporting cp - injured.
perin moves to benfica - injured. why are juve's rejects commanding such large transfer fees when they are not just injury prone, but not even fit to play?
on the 19th July, 2019 at 6:26pm
It's his own fault for going to Juve. You can't go far with such apparent lack of ambition. Only teams in Serie A that might need his service are relegation candidates though it's doubtful they even have the money to buy or pay his wages.
on the 19th July, 2019 at 2:00pm
If you look at this site, its like horribly narrow minded. It just cannot help but angle everything pro-Juventus...why its a failing site.
on the 19th July, 2019 at 1:44pm
This article makes it sound all gloomy and bleak, but all is not lost for Mattia.

For one, his shot-stopping qualities are, without equivocation, amongst the best in Italy and arguably in the world. Perin seldom concedes goals via howlers, like the pathetic Donnarumma, or De Gea, or Courtois.

Furthermore, fitness is something Mattia can work hard on and he'll truly shine. It's a shame we're selling him, as I honestly don't see Syzysceny remaining Juventus #1 for many years.

on the 19th July, 2019 at 1:09pm

Post new comment

Your email address is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
If you have your own website, enter its address here.
Maximum 500 characters.
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Enter the characters shown in the image.
Your responses will be moderated, and sometimes edited, by Football Italia before appearing on the site. Your data may be made public and you accept our Privacy Policy. Please keep your comments clean and try to keep them relevant to the blog above. We reserve the right to reject views that we deem unsuitable for publication.