Wednesday August 26 2020
Koulibaly perfect for Guardiola's City

Manchester City fans who don’t think Napoli defender Kalidou Koulibaly would be an ideal signing for Pep Guardiola are sorely mistaken, writes Kaustubh Pandey.

The Kalidou Koulibaly saga has been rumbling on for about three years now. It has knocked on the doors in every summer transfer window, as Napoli have always tried to catch some attention, create a bidding war and increase his asking price for potential suitors. That sentiment is reflected in every single statement that Aurelio De Laurentiis has given and his usual stubborn approach makes it seem pretty obvious.

With the passage of time, Koulibaly has aged, his contract is running down and his value has decreased as well. Napoli’s efforts to create an auction haven’t quite worked out. While Manchester City are still in the running, there’s a general sentiment amongst many that after three years, interest in the 29-year-old has only worn off.

In fairness, that perception is either down to a limited viewing of the Senegal international or an excessive consumption of FIFA 20, which has given birth to this idea that clubs should always sign players below the age of 27.

It is a cliche to suggest that Koulibaly is one of the best defenders in the world right now, but what would perhaps define him best is that he is a ‘Rolls Royce of a central defender’. He fits the profile of being a perfect Pep Guardiola figure and comparisons to Gerard Pique can easily be made. What he thrives on is breaking down opposition lines either carrying the ball or with his eye for reading a pass.

There were games this past season when Koulibaly hasn’t exactly looked his best. A case can be made of the fact that the 2019-20 campaign was probably Koulibaly’s worst over the last four seasons, partly due to injury in December, which meant he played just one game in 2020 before the June restart. The same can easily be said for the Partenopei themselves. It was a campaign which was marred with instability, boardroom friction, fractures between the owner, players and Carlo Ancelotti and a switch in mentality and style under Rino Gattuso.

One main issue under Ancelotti was the midfield combination in his favoured 4-4-2 shape. Due to the lack of a proper defensive midfielder, Napoli were constantly overrun in midfield and left Koulibaly and Kostas Manolas to deal with everything. Ancelotti even tried an advanced midfielder like Fabian Ruiz in the defensive midfield spot, apart from using Allan and Piotr Zielinski there anyway. The opposition would outnumber the midfield two and this became a common issue before Ancelotti got the sack following a Champions League win over RB Salzburg.

Gattuso came in and got every player on the club’s side once again after the whole training retreat row. He identified the midfield as the main issue that needed fixing. In came Diego Demme from RB Leipzig and long-term target Stanislav Lobotka joined from Celta Vigo. Demme has been silently crucial to their mini-revival and made Gattuso’s system look far more structured than Ancelotti’s was earlier in the season. Because of that, and of course the injury, it is hardly a coincidence that Koulibaly’s better performances have come in the second half of the season.

Every central defender in the world improves when he has the protection of the midfielders in front of him. Under Maurizio Sarri, Koulibaly played in a possession-oriented system that completed him as a footballer. His job wasn’t to constantly sit deeper and win aerial battles. The system played to his strengths. He had to move the ball forward quickly and use his smart reading of passing lanes to break the opposition down. He sought help from Jorginho’s progressive passing as well. He’s always been a threat in the air and what he did in the Sarri system is perhaps exactly why Guardiola likes him too.

Koulibaly and Jorginho would set the tone for Sarri’s approach. For a Man City side that was getting easily overrun this past season as a result of Fernandinho playing deeper and Aymeric Laporte’s injury, Koulibaly could be the perfect man to marshal the defence once the Brazilian starts doing the Jorginho job or Rodri grows into that sort of a player. So there is clearly a pattern here.

It is pretty easy to call Koulibaly ‘over-rated’ on the basis of his performance against Barcelona, which was poor. Again though, it comes down to the failure of the midfield in that game and a penalty which was rather unintentional. The Koulibaly-Manolas centre-half pairing hasn’t exactly been great either. The Greece international has been off it in many games himself.

There’s no denying that he isn’t getting any younger and won’t be as long-term a signing as someone like Pau Torres for Man City. But what they need is an experienced leader at the back, someone who can marshal his line the way Vincent Kompany did. Most of all, the player needs to know the system. As for Koulibaly, that is what he needs as well - someone who taps into his strengths and makes him do what Sarri allowed him to do. Guardiola would do just that.

Watch Serie A live in the UK on Premier Sports for just £9.99 per month including live LaLiga, Eredivisie, Scottish Cup Football and more. Visit:

Have your say...
@Token Bubble indeed, why, because this site is a juventus propagabda tool, they are always obsessively focused on speculating on Napoli players, they never fo that to Juventus players, or other Clubs for that matter, Napoli is the Club they all love to hate.
on the 30th August, 2020 at 10:38pm
Why is a site focusing on Italian Football, reporting on a Serie A player being the right fit for a Premier League side? Who cares about Manchester City!
on the 27th August, 2020 at 2:44pm
Time to sell. He's not as good as two seasons ago. Goes missing at crucial moments and is the cause for a lot of big goals Napoli concede.

Smart to sell.
on the 26th August, 2020 at 10:21pm
considering the project at napoli selling makes sense however napoli hold all the cards in this deal ideally they should push for a player swap like garcia plus a significant fee for koulibaly.

Moreover napoli need to improve in certain areas the lack of depth in the attack a replacement for callejon, more options in defence, a replacement for allan. the cash would be extremely useful for these objectives.
on the 26th August, 2020 at 7:39pm
Everyone loves this man, his demeanor and personality is such that fans have the greatest respect and admiration for Koulibaly. He has never been the fiery leader the team needed particularly in times of crisis and Napoli needs leaders. Gattuso gives the team leadership off the pitch but no one takes up the roll on it.
Certainly Koulibaly would be a great addition to a team that needs a solid defender on a competent top tier club, and the time has come for him to move on.
Napoli needs character
on the 26th August, 2020 at 1:48pm
Now is the time to cash in on Koulibaly it's the last chance to get a big fee for him, anything above £65million they should take and move on. They still have Manolas who could return to the form he showed at Roma, they have Rrhamani and with the funds they could pick up a replacement with plenty of options ranging from youngsters with potential such as Kumbulla/Milenkovic/Garcia/Ruben Dias/Pau Torres/Romero to more experienced players such as Umtiti or even Skriniar who may be available
on the 26th August, 2020 at 12:55pm
Regardless, it's time for Napoli to sell. At his age this will be their last shot at a good fee, and MC are desperate for proper defenders.

But, as always with ADL, he drags on forever with every transfer coming in or out, and therefore they've already lost a potential replacement in Gabriel.
on the 26th August, 2020 at 2:41am
What would Mercenary City "fans" know about top defenders?

Top defenders are a rare sight at that club.
on the 26th August, 2020 at 2:36am
After some of his Champions League performances I started to think that maybe Napoli should cash in on him. But there's just not that many great centre-back's around so unless they get a fair price or have spotted an adequate replacement, then I think they should hold onto him, if they can. I'm glad that Serie a clubs don't seem to be selling top players to the premier league at knockdown prices as much now. Which can only be better for serie a as a whole!
on the 26th August, 2020 at 1:25am

Post new comment

Your email address is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
If you have your own website, enter its address here.
Maximum 500 characters.
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Enter the characters shown in the image.
Your responses will be moderated, and sometimes edited, by Football Italia before appearing on the site. Your data may be made public and you accept our Privacy Policy. Please keep your comments clean and try to keep them relevant to the blog above. We reserve the right to reject views that we deem unsuitable for publication.