Wednesday December 19 2012
Should Cosmi have been sacked?

Siena’s loss at Fiorentina cost Coach Serse Cosmi his job. Luca Cetta asks if the Robur have made a mistake in firing Cosmi and hiring Beppe Iachini.

Twenty-seven long days. Since Giovanni Stroppa cleared out his desk at Pescara on November 18, Serie A had gone almost a month without waving goodbye to another tactician. And this is despite clubs owned by Maurizio Zamparini, Massimo Cellino and Enrico Preziosi all struggling. But like an itch that had to be scratched, one club acted. Siena bit the bullet, sending Serse Cosmi packing just over a week before he could eat his panettone.

In a League where two losses constitute a crisis, Siena had already overstepped that mark. Consecutive 3-1 home reverses to Roma and Catania were followed by a Tuscan Derby thumping, with Fiorentina cruising to a 4-1 victory. That heavy defeat confirmed the Robur’s position at the foot of the Serie A table. After 17 games they are four points from safety. But the situation is not as black and white as that.

Cosmi walked into a difficult situation this season. Siena’s typical aim to avoid relegation was compounded by the six point deduction received for their part in the betting scandal which has engulfed calcio the past two summers. Deduction included, they have amassed 11 points. Take away that penalty – which Cosmi could hardly be blamed for – and Siena would sit 15th, three points clear of the drop zone.

Just before the form slump which cost the eccentric Cosmi, his side was praised for their results. Eight points gained in four matches, all the while not conceding a goal, had thrown the Tuscans right into the mix. They did as would be hoped by defeating those around them – Genoa and Pescara – while claiming away draws at mid-table Parma and Chievo. Siena would then come up against two European contenders and the dangerous Sicilians.

The club may have been worried by Cosmi’s recent record. As President Massimo Mezzaroma alluded to, they believe the squad is equipped to survive.“I took the decision to change Coach after the defeat in Florence because I firmly believe in my players and our chances of staying up.”

Since hitting the heights at Perugia in the early 2000s Cosmi has found the going tough. He was unable to save Livorno in 2009-10, nor could Lecce avoid the drop last term under his leadership. But on both occasions he was asked to save ailing teams mid-season. And the question must be asked whether Siena have made much of an upgrade in appointing Giuseppe Iachini. In headwear at least, probably not. Out goes the dapper Cosmi flat cap, in comes the Iachini baseball cap.

Iachini succeeded in guiding Sampdoria from a stuttering Serie B campaign to the playoffs and, ultimately, the top flight last term. That he wasn’t retained speaks volumes. When given an opportunity in Serie A – at Chievo in 2008-09 and Brescia two seasons later – Iachini failed to welcome the New Year at either club.

The tactician says he can only do his best. “I’m accustomed to doing my talking on the pitch. I’ll give the maximum and all of my enthusiasm in order to achieve safety. I thank the club for their faith in me. We’ll look to add a building block to our survival plans on a daily basis.”

Iachini doesn’t have an easy start to life at the Stadio Artemio Franchi. They welcome a Napoli side smarting from a shock defeat and stung by the midweek verdicts. Siena then open 2013 with a trip to in-form Milan. Talk about a baptism of fire for Iachini. What will the hierarchy think if the rot continues? Meanwhile, Cosmi will have to hang up his cap for now and settle for panettone at home.

Watch Serie A live in the UK on Premier Sports and get your first month free. £5.99 thereafter until September with promo code: ITALIA

Have your say...
@Vito Doria, you raise some valid points, Cosmi does have the extenuating circumstances as an excuse.

I guess that I do not really rate Cosmi as a coach. He did well at Perugia, but then he did have the likes of Miccoli & Liverani in that team.

I have watched his teams many times, and I just feel that they have never defended well from the front, allowing his opponents to play with a high line, and seize the initiative. The performance against the Viola was terrible, there was no fight.
on the 19th December, 2012 at 3:16pm
I have the utmost respect for Serse Cosmi and his playing style. I also believe that he was the right man to save Siena from relegation.

In my opinion none will be better qualified for the job than Cosmi. Iachini isn't the answer and he will face the same issues as Cosmi did, only he won't deliver at all.

I wouldn't be surprised if we see Cosmi at Siena a few months from now taking over from Iachini and fighting to save them from going down.
on the 19th December, 2012 at 3:01pm
NO, cosmi should NOT have been sacked. there seems to be NO support for coaches that every day go to work and try their hardest with very limited too no resources. a small team, with zero expectations. actually, the only expectations they have every year is to not get relegated. not to mention point deductions as well. my feels are iachini will not change their fortunes. wishful thinking that at this point in time that siena will avoid the drop.
on the 19th December, 2012 at 2:47pm
@ Dan Giambrone

Cosmi has been getting some decent results this season and the points penalty doesn't help. Siena haven't been consistent but I doubt many coaches could have done better. Lecce were relegated last season but he did what he could after Eusebio Di Francesco left them in a huge mess. Even if they did survive, they would demoted anyway. Now they are in Lega Pro!
on the 19th December, 2012 at 2:16pm
A change had to be made. The club showed no signs of reversing their current slump under Cosmi. Their defending has been appalling. Cosmi was also at the helm when Lecce were relegated last season.

Siena do have some decent players and I believe that they can still survive, provided they hire coach who can organise them at the back.
on the 19th December, 2012 at 12:31pm
Even with Mourinho Siena would be where they are. I mean they would've been 14-15th if it wasn't for the deduction which was Sienas fault and not Cosmis. Iachini I may say will only send them deeper into problems. Cosmi is the coach for these teams, fighting for 'relegation'.
on the 19th December, 2012 at 12:09pm

Post new comment

Your email address is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
If you have your own website, enter its address here.
Maximum 500 characters.
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Enter the characters shown in the image.
Your responses will be moderated, and sometimes edited, by Football Italia before appearing on the site. Your data may be made public and you accept our Privacy Policy. Please keep your comments clean and try to keep them relevant to the blog above. We reserve the right to reject views that we deem unsuitable for publication.