Thursday January 24 2013
A dream gone wrong for Viviano

Is the pressure of playing for the team of his heart proving too much for Fiorentina’s Emiliano Viviano? Giancarlo Rinaldi writes.

Be careful what you wish for. Sometimes a long-dreamed goal can turn out to be a bit of a nightmare. Just ask Emiliano Viviano.

He was one of the jewels in the crown of Fiorentina's summer revolution at the end of some elaborate negotiations involving Inter and Palermo. For a man at home on the Curva Fiesole and with a daughter named Viola, there was never any doubt of the player's desires. Eventually, the deal was done which would effectively see him take the place of the freed Portiere Santo, Artur Boruc.

The first impact was fantastic. Viviano's permanent grin beamed brighter than the fog-lamps on a Ferrari as he lapped up donning his beloved club's colours. In a dressing room packed with South American imports, he let his teammates know what Fiorentina means to Florentines. With the World Cup in Brazil firmly in his sights, it seemed the perfect move for him to get regular first team football.

But what looked like a match made in heaven has started to assume a hellish aspect. A series of slip-ups started to raise question marks over whether playing for his hometown club was simply too much pressure. Was his desire to perform in purple just too intense?

With ambitious young Brazilian Norberto Neto – also harbouring World Cup dreams – breathing down his neck, Vincenzo Montella made a decision few would have expected at the start of this campaign. Viviano was injured, then omitted as his understudy took a starting role. Despite a clanger of his own against Udinese, it is a position the South American has held on to with a relatively firm grip.

That has left the fervent Fiorentino with nowhere to go. He remains a great dressing-room motivator, by all accounts, and influential figure from the touchline. But that simply is not enough for a goalkeeper who is at an age where he should be making his mark in Serie A week in, week out.

It has led to the embarrassing situation of him being hawked about to pretty much anyone who will take an interest. Montella appears to have decided that Neto is the man with the bold sideburns of Cristiano Lupatelli sufficient back-up. From being hailed as a hero, Viviano finds himself surplus to requirements.

It is the one bum note in the Viola revolution. A man who should have been at the centre of it, finds himself a peripheral figure. "Defending your goal, you defend your city. Emiliano pride of the Viola," proclaimed one banner on the Curva Fiesole at the weekend. But no amount of kind words can be dulling the pain he must be feeling that his dream move has not panned out.

Watching him warming up at half-time has become a painful pastime. He seems to be laughing and joking with his teammates but, inside, you know he must be hurting. To be so tantalisingly close to representing the club he supports must be a torture akin to unrequited love. It is not a fate anyone who holds the Viola dear would have wished on him.

A move away in the January transfer window looks the most likely solution – something which was unthinkable in the summer. It just underlines how even the best intentioned moves in football are not guaranteed to work out. Viviano will always have a Cuore Viola – a purple heart – but it may have to return to beating outside of Florence once more. 

Keep up to date with the latest news and action from Spain's Primera Division with Football Espana - from the team behind Football Italia.

See the latest Serie A predictions and betting tips with

Have your say...
It hurts but unfortunately Viviano isn't quite as good as Fiorentina need. Trouble is I don't think Neto is either (time may prove me wrong). The Viola need the likes of a Toldo or a Frey (in his good days).
on the 22nd July, 2013 at 2:01pm
Viviano is much better than Boruc ever was,while Neto is average at best,I honestly feel more confident at the start of the game if Viviano is in goal for us,FORZA VIOLA!
on the 13th July, 2013 at 11:56am
He will get another chance, Neto is average at best....terrible clanger against Udinese and should've saved Cavani's header last week.
Montella should show more faith in Viviano.
on the 26th January, 2013 at 1:00pm
Come on Emiliano.... knuckle down & snap out of this bad form.... you got what it takes to be a top class GK.
on the 24th January, 2013 at 3:54pm
He seems like he don't have the drive or determination to become one of the best keepers in Serie A. He shows little emotion and in my opinion the way he carries himself is what's doing him wrong. But the main point is he is not doing good at all.
on the 24th January, 2013 at 3:19pm
Indeed, have to agree with those who say that Viviano wasn't that good to begin with. He had a horrible last season with Palermo.

He doesn't make obvious clangers, but he leaves lots of shots unsaved that top GK-s like Marchetti, Handanovic or even Sorrentino etc are capable of getting.
on the 24th January, 2013 at 12:30pm
Is the pressure of playing for the team of his heart proving too much for Fiorentina’s Emiliano Viviano? -- NO. It's simply because he's not that good. From the start of his career, he's been overrated.
on the 24th January, 2013 at 11:27am
Its was a mistake leaving Inter where he would have been the possible custodian once julio cesar left. Playing for the big clubs always guareented a place even if that means as a back up to the indespensable buffon..
on the 24th January, 2013 at 11:16am
I have never rated Viviano. Sometimes we have a tendency to overhype some our young players, when there is little justification for it. Many players have gaps in their skill-sets, but with Viviano, I cannot think of any area in which he excels. You also have to wonder why both Inter and Palermo were so keen to move him on.
on the 24th January, 2013 at 10:35am
Really?? has he been that bad? Neto is not better, he should stay he will play again thats for sure.
on the 24th January, 2013 at 10:07am
It's feel terrible when he had a bad game against Roma. I really don't like this situation to Viviano, I Hope he will not go from Fiorentina. it's hard to find Florence boy become a legend in Fiorentina
on the 24th January, 2013 at 9:54am

Post new comment

Your email address is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
If you have your own website, enter its address here.
Maximum 500 characters.
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Enter the characters shown in the image.
Your responses will be moderated, and sometimes edited, by Football Italia before appearing on the site. Please keep your comments clean and try to keep them relevant to the blog above. We reserve the right to reject views that we deem unsuitable for publication.