Tuesday February 26 2013
The two faces of Montolivo

Riccardo Montolivo has stepped up to the challenge of playing for Milan, but he’s still an enigma for Italy. David Swan writes.

Silvio Berlusconi described him as "our Andrea Pirlo, now and in the future". And with those words the Milan President explained in a nutshell exactly why Riccardo Montolivo has stepped up and demonstrated the ability many people have been expecting from him for years at the top level, and at the same time struggles to impose himself for Italy.

He is now the main man in midfield for his club, a situation not too dissimilar to the one he had at Fiorentina. And just like his time in Florence he is responding with the performances we are still waiting to see with the national team on a consistent basis.

The comparison between club and country is not a completely fair one to make, but it offers insight into why there is a difference in performance. At Milan he is surrounded by comparatively inferior players technically so he naturally becomes the first option in midfield, and probably their only option given the lack of ability around him.

The passing stats reflect this, particularly in the important games. In those matches against other members of the current top six, Montolivo has made the most passes of any player on the team. He was playing to the right of another player in midfield in all bar last weekend’s derby and the home defeat to Fiorentina, so these numbers have not arisen by virtue of playing in front of the defence. Of course his position is not inflexible, but he tends to be a little further forward when Massimo Ambrosini or Nigel De Jong are stationed in front of the central defenders, meaning he is not always an easy short pass from the back four.

When he joins up with Azzurri it is a different story. At best he is the second option for the team and in a full strength Italy XI that drops to third. He still gets the ball, but perhaps mentally he does not feel as valued or as important when there are other players who receive it first.

The game against England at Euro 2012 is a good example, primarily because Italy were so dominant from around the 20th minute onwards, yet Montolivo was largely anonymous. The top two passing combinations had Daniele De Rossi and Pirlo as the ball receivers – and that is despite the former only playing 80 minutes, whereas Montolivo played the whole 120.

Indeed in the entire list of Italian passing combinations Montolivo’s name as a ball receiver does not appear until you reach the 11th combination, even though the total number of passes received shows he was found by teammates more than most of the other players in that night, leaving him ample opportunity to make his mark.

His position for Italy is a factor – he naturally will not be involved in as many combinations playing his unique brand of faux-trequartista football – though his average position in the England game was not that much further forward of Pirlo, hence why only the No 21 received the ball more during the match, and it does not stop his Milan colleagues from ensuring they find him on a regular basis. Yet while he continues to impose himself on games for the Rossoneri, he cannot do so for the Azzurri despite his teammates’ best efforts

Unless Milan continues to buy defensive midfielders, this is a problem he is going to eventually encounter at club level, with players of a similar technical ability playing in midfield alongside him. If he remains the go-to guy, all is well, if not, the mental hurdle he faces around 12 times a year is going to hit him every day.

Keep up to date with the latest news and action from Spain's Primera Division with Football Espana - from the team behind Football Italia.

Have your say...
You are basing it too much around his performance against England at the Euros, which is wrong. You shouldn't base your claims on one match and not only that, he played better from the second half onward.

He had a top match against Denmark and he is slowly improving for the Azzurri but he definitely do better. Having said that, he can't be the main regista for Italy but more of a decoy. Pirlo and Verratti can control play better and Montolivo could compliment one of the two.
on the 26th February, 2013 at 11:00am
The problem for Montolivio is I think he is better deep lke Pirlo, but Pirlo is the man still for Italy, I have to say though I dont think Milan other players lack technical quality around him, maybe he is just better than you think Nocerino Prince Ambro can all handle the ball, you could argue Pirlo has less techncal players around him which is why he stands out.. but we know thats not the case. His perfect role is the Pirlo role which he does so well but until Pirlo retires he wont play it.
on the 26th February, 2013 at 10:45am
Since Montolivo has moved to Milan his game has been a lot more consistent and he is showing what a talent he can be. Granted Milan aren't as strong as previous seasons but playing for a bigger club with better players brings the best out of him.
Montolivo was one of Italy's stand out performers at the Euro's, anyone who watched the games can testify that. So pointless stats about who passed to who in the England game are totally irrelevant.
on the 26th February, 2013 at 10:41am
Particularly if SES is the future. Balo can play through the middle with Giovinco or Diamanti or a fit Rossi as the third striker.
on the 26th February, 2013 at 10:41am
I don't believe that your assessment of his Italy performances are entirely fair. I think he came out of EURO 2012 with a lot of credit after a very difficult year in Florence. He was excellent against Germany in particular and performed a great function tactically. I think he has come a long way from WC 2010 when he did play well and seemed to lack the personality and confidence you allude to. For Milan, he was been superb of late and has been one of the standout midfield players in Europe.
on the 26th February, 2013 at 10:17am

Post new comment

Your email address is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
If you have your own website, enter its address here.
Maximum 500 characters.
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Enter the characters shown in the image.
Your responses will be moderated, and sometimes edited, by Football Italia before appearing on the site. Please keep your comments clean and try to keep them relevant to the blog above. We reserve the right to reject views that we deem unsuitable for publication.