Thursday March 14 2013
When a hat-trick is not enough

Victor Ibarbo scored a fine hat-trick at the weekend, but David Swan insists the Colombian is not yet the finished product.

If ever in doubt about a young player’s ability, the word ‘raw’ is a pretty good term to use. Chances are players that are described in this way possess many attributes needed to move on to a higher level, or have a career towards the top of the game, but are missing a few ingredients that will propel them in that direction. And if you are calling them raw, it probably means you are unsure whether they will ever develop the missing facets to their game.

Cagliari’s Victor Ibarbo, who scored a hat-trick at the weekend, is not far from fitting this description, so let’s get that word out there quickly – Ibarbo is a raw talent. There is so much to like about him, particularly physically where has more or less all the aspects you would look for in a modern forward – pace, power, height and all the rest.

“Ibarbo, when played on the right, is devastating if in form, though I have seen that he can also play in the centre,” claimed Coach Ivo Pulga back in December. “Now he has found the small details he was missing, he’s discovered speed over the first few metres.”

Pace, pace, pace – there is no guessing what the Colombian’s biggest asset is. And although none of the three goals he scored against Sampdoria on Sunday were a demonstration of this, a lot of his best performances have come where he has been able to stretch his legs and give defensive lines problems in behind – Milan and Roma this season spring to mind.

Atalanta Coach Stefano Colantuono described Ibarbo, along with Marco Sau and Thiago Ribeiro, as a player that can “kill you” with his speed with and without the ball, warning his players in the process.

But therein lies the danger for the 23-year-old – he is becoming known for his pace and not much else. The reason for that is because once he gets to the penalty area he is rarely decisive – games like Sunday are all too infrequent. Forget comparisons with the players at better teams and instead compare him to teammate Sau, who is also quick but has managed to score 11 goals this season. Ibarbo has four, three of which came on Sunday.

Sau of course has the luxury of playing centrally, while Ibarbo spends most of his time out wide. Yet the two have created the same number of goals – a measly one – as each other over the course of the season. Ibarbo’s numbers do not match the rest of his game, and for everything Pulga thinks he has added since last season, the productivity has not improved.

As long as that stays the case, he will remain one of those players whose name will appear on a list of possible dangermen on the preview sheets, but who won’t definitively be the one to watch.

Keep up to date with the latest news and action from Spain's Primera Division with Football Espana - from the team behind Football Italia.

Have your say...
He seems like a really good player. He is not 23 yet and he will improve his scoring but he could a phenomenal world class player. Have should snatch him and he can their star.
on the 16th March, 2013 at 8:41am
he has been performing above the expected every since he touched down in sardegna. He is a wonderful talent, and slowly goals will compliment the rest of his all round game. if Ibarbo was brazilian, a bigger club on the peninsula would have snapped him up by now. but being surrounded by older and wiser heads in conti, pinilla and radja, I'm sure he will only get better. certainly only seeing him as pacey is a grave injustice. he can head the ball, a towering physique and has bags of confidence.
on the 14th March, 2013 at 12:10pm

Post new comment

Your email address is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
If you have your own website, enter its address here.
Maximum 500 characters.
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Enter the characters shown in the image.
Your responses will be moderated, and sometimes edited, by Football Italia before appearing on the site. Please keep your comments clean and try to keep them relevant to the blog above. We reserve the right to reject views that we deem unsuitable for publication.