Friday March 7 2014
Juve and Fiorentina, best of enemies

Richard Thomas investigates the Juventus-Fiorentina rivalry and is convinced that a new, controversial chapter is waiting to be written over the next fortnight.

It would be the understatement of the century to say there is no love lost whenever Juventus and Fiorentina go head to head. To put it simply, fans of the two clubs cannot stand one other. But why?

The cities of Florence and Turin lie approximately 400 kilometres apart, meaning geographical proximity can hardly be considered a factor. Neither, even the most ardent Viola fan would admit, do the two clubs boast remotely comparable trophy hauls. Juve have won 29 official Scudetti to Fiorentina’s comparatively meagre two. The Bianconeri also have nine Coppa Italias, two European Cups, three UEFA Cups and one Cup Winners’ Cup to their name. The Florence outfit have six, zero, zero and one respectively. While still a total that is the envy of the vast majority of clubs around the peninsula, the Viola have not slugged it out for honours with their old foes on a particularly regular basis.

Perhaps this is the root of the hatred in another sense though. On one of the few occasions Fiorentina have managed to go toe to toe with the Old Lady over the course of a season, they, to this day, feel they were robbed of a rare moment of glory. The year was 1982 and heading into the final day of the Serie A season the two sides were level on points at the top of the table. The Viola were chasing their third Scudetto and travelled to Cagliari, while the Bianconeri were after their 20th and prepared to take on Catanzaro. The rest is, as they say, history. The men from Tuscany had a seemingly legitimate second half goal chalked off and could only muster a goalless draw in Sardinia. Over in Calabria meanwhile, Catanzaro had strong appeals for a penalty turned down before Juve themselves were awarded a dubious one. Liam Brady tucked it away and, before you could say ‘ladri’ - thieves in Italian - the Old Lady were champions once again. What is it with Fiorentina and referees?

Viola fans have never quite gotten over this perceived injustice and events since have only escalated the ill-feeling between the clubs. Fast forward to 1990 and a certain Roberto Baggio had become the new darling of the Artemio Franchi, only for that pesky Old Lady to stick her nose in where it wasn’t wanted once more. Taking advantage of the Viola owners’ willingness to cash in on their star man, Juve paid a then world record €10m to land the player and with it, send the city of Florence into a state of anarchy. Full scale rioting occurred and around 50 people were injured.

On the off chance that this wasn’t enough to incense everyone with a persuasion for purple, for good measure the Bianconeri beat their old adversaries in that season’s UEFA Cup Final while the saga was ongoing. It didn’t end there though – when the sides faced each other in Florence the following season, Baggio refused to take a penalty awarded to Juve against his old side and later even left the field with a Viola scarf around his neck. Acts that needless to say did not go down well with fans of the club who paid his wages.

More recently, the two clubs were once again at loggerheads in the summer of 2012 when the Old Lady made a late attempt to hijack Fiorentina’s attempts to sign Dimitar Berbatov from Manchester United. In the end the Bulgarian chose to move to neither of them but this did not stop the Viola then issuing an official statement attacking Juve’s ‘reckless and arrogant actions’ and claiming that the Turin club ‘knew nothing of the values of honesty, fair play and sporting ethics’.

Quite a shared history then, and one which makes the prospect of these two grand old Italian footballing institutions locking horns not once, not twice, but thrice over the next fortnight all the more mouth-watering for the neutral. After facing off at Juventus Stadium in Serie A this Sunday, the two sides will meet again in Turin for the first leg of their Europa League Last 16 tie four days later. A week later comes the return at what is sure to be a rocking Artemio Franchi, after which another new and fiery chapter will have surely been written in one of Italian calcio’s most bitter rivalries.

The scene is perfectly set for this. As has so often been the case down the years, Juve come into the games as clear favourites and in the hunt for trophies once again. The Scudetto is theirs to lose once more and in the League game at least Fiorentina will be reduced to the role of trying to halt their rivals’ title charge as opposed to challenging to win it themselves.

This is not to say Vincenzo Montella’s side don’t need the three points – far from it, they need them very badly if they are to maintain any hope of catching Napoli in third place and securing Champions League qualification. They have shown they are capable of getting them too, being the only team to beat Antonio Conte’s winning machine in Serie A so far this season.

The Viola will also have the chance to really hurt the Bionconeri in Europe. Victory against the Old Lady over two Europa League legs would end their hopes of playing a final that they themselves are hosting. It would also clear a sizeable obstacle on the Florence side’s own potential path to glory. Juve meanwhile are the tournament favourites and their motivation is clear.

Both sides have it all to play for and as this much anticipated three-part drama approaches, the two chief protagonists have been cast in their familiar historical roles. The Bianconeri are on another relentless march to glory and will not want their old adversaries getting too big for their boots, while the Viola will be desperate to finally rise from the shadows of their illustrious rivals and write their own little piece of history. Oh, and they have recently had some well-publicised grievances with referees. Now where have we heard that before?

Have your say...
Great article. ..Gabriel, great comment.
on the 9th March, 2014 at 11:07am
legitimate second half goal ... Catanzaro had strong appeals for a penalty turned down before Juve themselves were awarded a dubious one using word like legitimate or dubious doesn't give you credibility nor change the fact ... there is foul on Cagliari keeper & juve had clear penalty it's obvious now after calciopolli losers using the referee as hanger to their failure JUVE have won on their entire history ... and history REPEAT ITSELF !!!!
on the 9th March, 2014 at 8:39am
My view precisely Gabriel. As a Juve fan I have no real reason to hate Fiorentina or their fans. However, one thing I don't take kindly is that appalling countdown to 39 followed by a cheer. Sure, some Juve fans in stadiums are no saints either but the lack of grace that Fiorentina and Inter continually show towards us using whatever pathetic excuse they can get their hands on proves that they are not worthy of our wrath. I'm just hoping for some spectacular games this month between us
on the 9th March, 2014 at 12:45am
chuck it dude. thats not gonna happen .We will make sure that we dent juve's hopes of winning the scudetto early
on the 8th March, 2014 at 4:01pm
@ Anonymous
First of all you need to understand the correct use of grammar before trying to write a comment. Secondly, if you are going to bring up Calciopoli, then please at least read up on what really happened before commenting. Juventus were guilty of nothing more than making phone calls to the refereeing designator, something every other club did. There was no evidence of match-fixing or sporting fraud. Also the chief prosecutor was a former Inter director, so who were the real criminals?
on the 8th March, 2014 at 1:44pm
Well said Gabriel.
on the 8th March, 2014 at 8:06am
@Gabriel..are you saying that Juve where arrogant when knocked out of champions league the coppa Italia, then you need to understand football a little better. And just for your will be there 30th scudetto, as they were found guilty if calciopoli...
on the 8th March, 2014 at 6:16am
The rivalry comes predominately from Florence. Do we consider Fiorentina rivals of any!!
Fiorentina deservedly beat us in October and they celebrated like they had won their 3rd Scudetto. We were terribly arrogant that day and got what we deserved, but we haven't lost since and we will beat them on Sunday and take another step towards our 32nd Scudetto. At this moment we have no rivals and it's up to the rest to get better and challenge us. We are back on top and we are not going away.
on the 7th March, 2014 at 11:43pm

Post new comment

Your email address is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
If you have your own website, enter its address here.
Maximum 500 characters.
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Enter the characters shown in the image.
Your responses will be moderated, and sometimes edited, by Football Italia before appearing on the site. Please keep your comments clean and try to keep them relevant to the blog above. We reserve the right to reject views that we deem unsuitable for publication.