Saturday March 29 2014
Continuity key in calcio!

Serie A’s overachievers this season all have one thing in common and it should serve as an example to other clubs, says Richard Thomas.

By the time the average Italian football Coach reaches a certain age, his CV would seem to resemble a list of stops on a particularly long, arduous and confusing train journey rather than an account of his actual footballing accomplishments.

Take Udinese’s Francesco Guidolin, for example. His particular voyage departed from Giorgione in 1988 and briefly called at Treviso, Fanno, Empoli, Ravenna and Atalanta before a lengthier stopover at Vicenza. Udinese, Bologna, Palermo, Genoa and Monaco then preceded a farcical two-year period during which he was flagged back in, then waved away again, three times by whistle-happy Rosanero conductor Maurizio Zamparini.

The locomotive of the 58-year-old’s career appeared to have ground to a confusion-induced halt in Sicily, but it eventually got back on the right track and headed for Parma before pulling back into another old haunt, Udinese, where it has remained ever since. Will that be his final destination though?

In his 26 years as a senior Coach, Guidolin has had a whopping 17 jobs. His nomadic career is an example of the norm rather than the exception in Italy and casts light on an almost laughable lack of forward thinking and perspective that many clubs have to this day. The most recent example of this was Sassuolo’s decision this month to reappoint Eusebio Di Francesco less than two months after sacking and replacing him with Alberto Malesani. If Di Francesco wasn’t the man to keep the Neroverdi up in January, why is he now? The logic behind the whole saga seems at best extremely flawed and at worst completely non-existent.

Perhaps some Presidents around the peninsula are finally starting to see sense, though. Guidolin is heading towards his four-year anniversary at the helm in Udine where, despite a slightly underwhelming season this time around, he has done a fine job overall. With limited resources, he has twice gained Champions League qualification and won the prestigious Panchina d’Oro in 2011 as recognition for his efforts. Perhaps if Zamparini had allowed Guidolin the time and space to do his job properly at Palermo it would have been them who reaped those rewards. Instead, they are currently fighting to get out of Serie B.

It is no coincidence that all of Serie A’s other surprise packages this season have had their Coaches in place for a considerable amount of time too. Stefano Colantuono arrived at Atalanta in 2010 and has made La Dea a firm fixture in Italy’s top flight again. They currently sit seventh and look set for a top half finish at the very least this season. “It’s strange in today’s game,” he admitted when asked about his ‘long’ tenure so far. “But I want to build something important here with players I know inside out.”

It’s a similar story at Verona, who are still having an excellent season despite their recent slump and have had Andrea Mandorlini in place for four years. Giampiero Ventura has been at Torino for three and has the mid-table Granata playing with skill and flair following promotion in 2012. Though Parma, perhaps the biggest overachievers of the lot, only appointed Roberto Donadoni in 2012, they too have a clear long term plan for stability. “The youth academy’s results are showing that we are doing our jobs well,” President Tommaso Ghirardi recently said. “We have built a medical rehabilitation centre and a club house that allows the players to eat and sleep in the same place. I think even that has played a part in helping us produce good players.”

By contrast, anarchy reigns supreme at the bottom and Chievo are incredibly the only one of the League’s lowest five placed clubs not to have changed their Coach at least once since the start of 2014. They, incidentally, look the best placed of the relegation contenders to avoid the drop. Sassuolo on the other hand look set for a return to the second tier following a shambolic couple of months.

If ever there were a season that so clearly demonstrated the benefits of long term forward planning over looking for short term quick fixes, it is this one. As the end of the season approaches and club Presidents around the country rack their brains wondering what has gone wrong over the last eight months, they would be well served to look at just how the likes of Atalanta, Udinese, Torino, Verona and Parma put foundations in place to become greater than the sum of their parts. That means you too, Silvio.

Keep up to date with the latest news and action from Spain's Primera Division with Football Espana - from the team behind Football Italia.

See the latest Serie A predictions and betting tips with

Have your say...
This is not a good argument. The clubs mentioned are not expected to win the title, cup or even qualify for Europe. Their only objective is to survive & have some good wins along the way so the coaches are not under any pressure & can work with no interference.
on the 30th March, 2014 at 9:35pm
@ st ambrose in fairness to milan they do not tend to go through too many coaches. They stuck by allegri even last season and it paid dividends in the end with CL qualification. This season his job became untenable because the results were so bad. Galliani really should've gone years ago but has somehow stayed. The issues at milan are different
on the 30th March, 2014 at 12:16pm
This is a flawed argument. A coach can only be kept in a position when he is winning, or has numerous, well-set ideas and a direction for the team. De Francesco has done nothing for Sassuolo in Serie A, hence I don't know why he should have been kept on any longer than he was initially sacked. Torino, Verona and Parma all have visionary transfer policies that equips the coach to perform. If a coach is to succeed, the club cannot be run by amateurs.
on the 30th March, 2014 at 8:06am
The problem is similar to what teachers face. Because everyone has gone to school, they all think they know better than the teacher. These club presidents and owners think they know better. Until you have experience on the bench coaching, you just don't understand. The old expression is apt, "you can't make a silk purse out of a pig's ear." As with a teacher with an assigned class or a coach with any group of players, you can only do so much with what you are given.
on the 29th March, 2014 at 9:39pm
The reason you see these head-scratching coaching moves made by clubs is a restriction in the Italian game that forces clubs to pay the remainder of a coaches contract even after termination. When Malesani was dismissed it was much cheaper to bring back Di Francesco as Sassuolo were already paying him anyways rather than sign a new coach. In turn clubs use a small pool of coaching changes to motivate the squad. If Italian football wants to move forward the FIGC need to address that.
on the 29th March, 2014 at 3:31pm
In terms of forward thinking Serie A is far behind the other big European leagues. The sad thing is the presidents of most Serie A clubs can't see this, and blame the economy for the poor performances of Serie A clubs.
on the 29th March, 2014 at 12:42pm
I appreciate the Berlusconi remark in the final sentence. It was on my mind throughout the article. The evidence put forward here is very interesting.
on the 29th March, 2014 at 11:32am

Post new comment

Your email address is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
If you have your own website, enter its address here.
Maximum 500 characters.
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Enter the characters shown in the image.
Your responses will be moderated, and sometimes edited, by Football Italia before appearing on the site. Please keep your comments clean and try to keep them relevant to the blog above. We reserve the right to reject views that we deem unsuitable for publication.