Thursday July 28 2016
Will Pogba pick fool's gold or logic?

Paul Pogba’s future has been the subject of debate all year long, but in the end Juventus will always be a winner, writes Vincent Van Genechten.

Will he stay or will he go? That’s been the question for months regarding Paul Pogba. One thing’s for sure: whatever the outcome will be, the football world will show signs of relief. This transfer saga has been going on for so long, with so many chapters written, that it has turned into a source of frustration for everyone involved and everyone interested.

“Paul Pogba will join Manchester United in the next 48 hours.” That’s the story of this week. But it was a story before, so a bunch of fans have just given up and are waiting for Ed Woodward, Beppe Marotta, Mino Raiola or Pogba himself to announce ‘The Decision’. Pogba wearing a LeBron James jersey on vacation in the Unites States did have a meaning…

Of course, there’s always some news outlet that will exaggerate a random Instagram post by the France international, who has also added fuel to the rumours by remaining very silent on the matter and sometimes posting mysterious stuff on his social media accounts.

The fact is: no one knows what Pogba wants except for Pogba. However, whatever his choice will be, the Old Lady will benefit from it. If he leaves, Juve will have a record amount to spend on a couple of quality replacements. If he stays, Juve will be able to pair Pogba with the likes of Gonzalo Higuain and Miralem Pjanic, alongside Paulo Dybala.

When talking purely about football, it would be pretty foolish for the 23-year-old to leave the club that has put so much faith in him. The Bianconeri even handed him the iconic number 10 last summer, making him the face of the franchise. A decade after being relegated to Serie B, Juventus are back at the top of the football world and ready to launch an assault on the Champions League, the one trophy that has escaped them since 1996.

Juve’s ambition has been so outspoken that it seemingly has become their second nature. Coach Max Allegri can’t stop mentioning it, while every new signing talked about being in Turin to win the cup with the big ears, from Higuain to Pjanic and even Marko Pjaca. This ambition strokes with Pogba’s, who also has a big desire to win the Ballon d’Or, a feat he could accomplish at Juve next season.

However, it’s hard to ignore cold, hard cash. Even with Pogba having zero financial troubles, getting paid three times as much as you are at the moment is tempting. In addition, the midfielder has some scores to settle at Old Trafford, as the club let him leave for free four years ago. It is true that it remains his first home…

Still, United don’t play Champions League football next season, meaning Pogba would join a team that’s starting a new cycle. On a club level, he’ll be back to 2012, when Juve were just getting started. Again, football-wise it would make zero sense for the Frenchman to leave.

And then, there’s the pressure. Pogba will be the most expensive footballer on the planet. Every move he makes will be analysed and every mistake will be noticed, especially in England. Like with Gareth Bale, whatever Pogba does, it will never be enough. Ever. That’s the cruelty of the whole story.

At Juventus, he is the man, while playing in a system and position that suits him perfectly. At United, everything remains to be seen. Pogba is a gamer, meaning he would accept the challenge, but does he really want all the trouble that comes with it?

Here’s how Juventus should do it: talk Pogba into staying for two more seasons. In 2018, Gigi Buffon and Andrea Barzagli will retire, hopefully with a Champions League under their belts, while Pogba has won it all. If he wants to leave then, do everything in your power to sell him for the best offer available. Because, does anyone really believe that in two years, the big offers won’t come for Pogboom?

All things considered, it’s logical for Paul Pogba to remain at Juventus for just a little while. But in football, logic often isn’t the guideline.

Watch Serie A live in the UK on Premier Sports for just £9.99 per month including live LaLiga, Eredivisie, Scottish Cup Football and more. Visit:

Have your say...
Whatever Pogba decide it is juventus who will gain the most. As juventino, I rather see pogba join united and collect that huge ammount of money because im sure juve will bring in more quality players with it.
on the 28th July, 2016 at 12:21pm
Juventus aren't a "franchise", they are a club.
on the 28th July, 2016 at 11:41am
isn't the pogba transfer going to happen to fund the higuain transfer? or do Juve have the means to spend that sort of money without selling and getting any FFP sanctions these days?
on the 28th July, 2016 at 11:36am
Paul should read this, staying for 2 more years for him it would be perfect solution for him, there will also be World Cup at the time in Russia.
on the 28th July, 2016 at 11:24am
I kind of don't care about this guy or his agent now, just get on with it already leave just go! Juve will be better off anyways with the money, they can possibly sign another world class star in the midfield maybe even try get Verratti for like 80million or something. With or without Pogba they are so strong and have good chance to win in europe.
on the 28th July, 2016 at 11:09am
I personally don't care for Juve, but for the 'health' of Serie A, I hope that Pogba stays. If Serie A wants to be one of the best leagues in Europe once again, it can only do so by having the best talent available in its teams. It is one thing being strong domestically, but in Europe it is completely different. It is already bad enough that Germany have surpassed Italy in the UEFA coefficients, so having weak domestic teams will only reduce the number of Serie A teams entering CL/Europa League.
on the 28th July, 2016 at 11:04am
Can't agree more with this article. While winning the champions league is no easy thing, no matter how strong your team is, this is the best chance he'd have since joining Juve. I can't see why someone would leave to go to a team that is in transition and playing Europa League. I don't think Juve would struggle very much with him gone, but they certainly wouldn't be worse off with him staying. Money is important, but at 23, he can always move for the money later, once the team he wants is in CL.
on the 28th July, 2016 at 11:03am

Post new comment

Your email address is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
If you have your own website, enter its address here.
Maximum 500 characters.
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Enter the characters shown in the image.
Your responses will be moderated, and sometimes edited, by Football Italia before appearing on the site. Your data may be made public and you accept our Privacy Policy. Please keep your comments clean and try to keep them relevant to the blog above. We reserve the right to reject views that we deem unsuitable for publication.