Juventus were held to a 1-1 draw by Crotone after a Simy spot-kick, but Alvaro Morata scored one, had another chalked offside and saw Federico Chiesa controversially sent off.
The Bianconeri stuttered again in Calabria against the newly-promoted side, forced to do without several key players including Cristiano Ronaldo and Aaron Ramsey.
Leonardo Bonucci’s mistimed tackle saw Simy convert a penalty, cancelled out by Morata meeting a Chiesa assist.
However, the former Fiorentina starlet’s debut took a turn for the worse with a straight red card for his challenge on Luca Cigarini.
Even down to 10 men, Juventus almost won it with Morata, but his goal was narrowly ruled offside.